The 5 Most Popular Pizza Toppings

About 1 in every 8 Americans consumes pizza on any given day. On these days, this pizza gave them about 25% of their total daily energy.

If you’re looking to join these numbers, ordering the best pizza toppings available needs to be a priority.

Read on to learn about the most popular toppings in the US!

Pizza with various toppings

Table of Contents

1. Pepperoni

Pepperoni is the #1 most-loved pizza topping in America. 64% of Americans surveyed stated that they liked pepperoni pizza. In the poll of 6000 people, that amounts to 3840 individuals.

Pepperoni pizza is one of the great staples of food lovers. It’s a classic for a reason- the smoky taste of the meat is a great contrast against the gooey cheese and rich tomato sauce. There’s nothing not to love, and no other topping (or combination of toppings) can match its appeal.

2. Sausage

Though sausage is the 2nd most popular US pizza topping, its popularity doesn’t come close to pepperoni. 56% of survey-takers ticked the box denoting that they liked it. This is a high figure, but it’s still 8% lower than those who loved pepperoni.

If you’re a meat-lover, pairing pepperoni with sausage is a great way to get a bit of extra protein on your pie. Plus, since the smoky pepperoni flavor and the salt of sausage go amazingly well together, you won’t regret this throwing this combo into your outdoor pizza oven.

3. Mushrooms

Are you a vegetarian that’s feeling discouraged by the above answers? You’re in luck- mushrooms are America’s 3rd favorite pizza topping. With 54% of survey responders citing a love for mushrooms, its popularity is only 2% lower than that of meat toppings.

Mushrooms add a unique smell, taste, and texture to any pizza. They’re satisfying to bite through and delicious when paired with cheesy goodness. They also are a great source of fiber, iron, and necessary vitamins.

4. Extra Cheese

There are tons of biological and social reasons that human beings love cheese, and we love it even more on pizza. It makes sense that 52% of people prefer to have extra cheese on their pizza rather than only a small amount.

Pizza with extra cheese is ridiculously easy to make at home. All you need to do is select multiple cheese types and evenly distribute them across your homemade pie. The best gooey four-cheese pizzas contain not just mozzarella but also white cheddar, Monterey Jack, and parmesan.

5. Onions

Onions, America’s 5th most favorite pizza topping, only have a 48% acceptance rate. Still, it’s beloved among those who enjoy adding some extra crunch and distinctive flavor to their favorite pies.

If you love onion but want a more balanced flavor, pairing it with green peppers is a good way to go. They’re fresh and juicy while toning down the strong onion flavor slightly.

Related: Who Invented Pizza?

Cook With the Best Pizza Toppings Today

While there are hundreds of pizza toppings that you can choose from, you can’t go wrong with the classics. Whether you’re a carnivore or a vegetarian, there’s a delicious traditional option you’re sure to love. Contact Yard Cave with any questions that you have about pizza toppings, ovens, and beyond.